What is the Best Hair Dye for Men – Reviews & Ratings

Last Updated February 21, 2024

It doesn’t take much, women are not the only people with the luxury to dye their hair. Men can do it too. There are plenty of hair dyes with a variety of hair shades to help men look their best. The trick is to find the one that complements your natural hair color.

You have never colored your hair before? Don't worry. In this roundup, we are going to look at and review 5 different hair dyes for men. Finding the right and simple hair color for men is difficult as all men’s hair are not the same. These top 5 hair dye products for men should make that search a lot easier and help them look more stylish.

We thought the Just For Men Control GX Grey Reducing Shampoo was the best. To find out our reasons for this selection just continue to read our review.

review of the best hair dye for men

The Best Hair Dye for Men Product Overview

  1. Just For Men Control GX Grey Reducing Shampoo - this is a nice way to change your hair color without looking like you dyed your hair the night before. It is easy to apply and should not stain your face. Subtle changes are nice changes
  2. Clairol Natural Instincts Semi Permanent Hair Dye Kit - this product works simply. All you need to do is apply it straight to your problem spots and wait 20 minutes. When that time is up, just rinse and your gray should not be around anymore. Special conditioner helps keep the new look
  3. Just For Men Original Formula, Gray Hair Coloring for Men - This is an 8 week long lasting hair color dye that makes sure the gray stays away. Its 5-minute application frees up more time and lets you get back to doing more important activities quickly
  4. Just For Men Easy Comb-In Color - coloring your hair is as natural as combing it. That is what this product does. It lets you comb your color in so your gray disappears without a mess or a fuss. The color lasts as well.
  5. Just For Men Original Formula, Gray Hair Coloring for Men - the original formula that helps men look years younger. It is easy to apply and the color should remain for 8 weeks.

Reviews of the Best Hair Dye for Men on the Market

Hair Color
Grey Coverage?
Editor's Rating


All Shades






Sandy Blonde

It's okay


Medium Brown

It's okay


Real Black

It's okay

#1. Just For Men Control GX Grey Reducing Shampoo (BEST HAIR DYE FOR Men with Grey Hair)

Get rid of that gray hair without having to use expensive hair dyes or color agents. This men’s hair shampoo slowly dyes your hair when you wash it in the shower. That is a quick convenient way to get rid of those gray hairs that make you look older than you really are.

This product is a safe hair dye for men because inside this shampoo are the natural ingredients hemp and arginine. These ingredients help to slowly color your hair so that no one will notice a difference until the task is done. Even then they may not notice as the change is very subtle.

All you have to do is replace your normal shampoo. It is that easy. Then when you get to a point where you like what you see, you can stop using it. To maintain that look, you just alternate between using your regular shampoo and this shampoo dye alternative.

While it is good for all shades of hair, for best results use it on light brown to black hair colors. The good news is that this shampoo should not stain your face.

If you want a good men's hair dye that targets grey hairs, then this product is definitely your best choice.

 Just For Men Control GX Grey Reducing Shampoo Review

What We Like

  • Subtle color change
  • Easy to use
  • Does not stain skin
  • Has natural ingredients
  • For all hair color shades

What We Don't Like

  • May leave black residue in your tub or shower
  • Where's plastic gloves?
  • Leaves a slight odor

#2. Clairol Natural Instincts Semi-Permanent Hair Dye Kit (Best Natural Hair Dye for Men)

You have heard all the horror stories about dying your hair. This product should alleviate those fears and have you dying your hair every time the gray appears. It is made from natural ingredients like vitamin E, aloe, and protein and does not contain ammonia.

Once you bring this box home, and color your hair, that result should remain through 28 shampoos. All you have to do is apply the mixture to your hair where the gray is the worst and move on from that point. Don’t shave if you are going to apply it to your facial hair.

After you have done that, you need to use a nickel-sized worth of the included conditioner to keep your hair looking great. Once a week treatment is all you need to keep your hair looking great.

When you are done your hair should have a nice deep brownish black color hue that should make your eyes pop. This product is not hard to use but you can always get help from your girlfriend to make sure it is done right.

Clairol Natural Instincts Semi-Permanent Hair Dye Kit  Review

What We Like

  • Comes with conditioner
  • Gets rid of the gray
  • Just wait 20 minutes and rinse

What We Don't Like

  • May make your skin itch
  • Results may vary

They say it is the best hair dye for black men because the blond color works well against the black skin. That is just one reason any man should use this hair dye. This dye helps target gray hair and provides you with natural looking hair shade.

With its natural ingredients, keratin, olive oil and vitamin E, and the lack of ammonia not only do you get great looking hair, the look remains for up to 2 months. The gray will grow back before the color washes out.

To get the hair dye ready just pour the mixture into the applicator bottle and shake well. In about 5 minutes your hair will be gray free. Make sure to follow the instructions on the information sheet inside. Also, do an allergy test first just to be sure you can use this product safely?

One nice thing about this brand of hair dye is that if sandy blonde is not your choice of colors, you have over 10 more to select from. A hassle-free hair dye is a great way to take years off your look.

Just For Men Original Formula Sandy Blonde Review

What We Like

  • Hassle-free
  • Short dying period
  • Lasts for 8 weeks
  • Natural ingredients

What We Don't Like

  • Color results may not match box color
  • May grow darker over time
  • May change hair texture

#4. Just For Men Easy Comb-In Color (Best Hair Dye for Men with Short Hair)

The special formula in this hair dye for men stops coloring your hair after 10 minutes. That automatic feature protects you from going too dark with the hair color. Once you have opened the package you will find that there is no mixing, no mess and no fuss. Just comb the color back into your hair.

Like other hair dyes from this company, the color should stay where you put it for 8 weeks. When the grey hairs grow back you will know it is time for another treatment. What makes it great for men with short hair is that you simply comb it in and do not use all the color in the bottle.

After you open the package just attach the comb section to the color tube and comb your hair like normal. Then wait ten minutes and rinse. It is so easy your kids could do it for you and not make a mistake.

There is no ammonia nor peroxide ingredients but at the same time, there are no natural ingredients either. Do an allergy test prior to using?

Just For Men Easy Comb-In Color Review

What We Like

  • The comb feature
  • No mixing
  • Easy to rinse out

What We Don't Like

  • Tube may not go that far
  • Can’t seem to cover tough gray hair
  • Color does not last that long

Target the gray hair on your head. This real jet black hair dye restores your natural color and removes that gray that is making you look older than you want to look. Once you are done, your hair should look like a professional did the deed.

The natural ingredients, keratin, olive oil and vitamin E, make sure your hair looks healthy and shiny. With no ammonia in the dye, your hair should be safe from harsh chemicals.

Then if real black is not your hair color, check out the other 12 hair color shades this dye comes in. After you are done, the gray should be gone for about 8 weeks. A little shake and 5 minutes and your hair color is restored minus the gray.

3 packs of hair dye are included in the box. This lets you keep your hair looking great for 6 months or more.

Just For Men Original Formula Real Black Review

What We Like

  • Original formula
  • Easy to use
  • Need only 5 minutes
  • Lots of color variety
  • 3 pack

What We Don't Like

  • Color didn’t last
  • Some hair fall out

What We Found Out...

During our research, we found out that there are very few good men's hair coloring dye brands to choose from. That is okay as men do not think about dying their hair as much as women do.

Also, there are fewer hair shades for men to choose from. Some men like dark hair colors while some like lighter shade. This lack of selection shouldn’t bother a man as they can always use the ones made for women.

Most of the men's hair dyes reviewed on this article is easy to use so that you can dye your hair at home without any hassle.

Should Men Dye Their Hair?

This will depend on whom you are talking to. While some men may think it is okay to dye their hair, there are just as many that say they shouldn’t. One of the reasons for this is that those opponents to men dying their hair claim the result looks fake.

Maybe on some men, it does but not on all men. Those opponents also say that those men who color their hair do not understand what women find attractive in a man. But that is up to each man to decide for themselves.

If they want to dye their hair, let them. They are not hurting anyone and only helping the economy. In some cases those men that dye their hair look stylish and part of the in-crowd.

What is the Best Color Hair Dye for Men?

best hair color for men

There are two options that fit this category the best. First, the experts say that an ash tone works for almost all men. Then they say that warm color tones do a great job in helping men look their best if they have reddish tones.

Cool colors work better for everyone else. The criteria to selecting your hair dye is to go with those subtle tones that complement your actual hair color. The key may be in the price. The more expensive brands nay give you a more natural look than the inexpensive options you can purchase.

How to Dye Men’s Hair?

There are some simple steps to dying men’s hair.

  • Step #1, Read the instructions first.
  • Step #2, After you have done that mix the hair dye so it is ready to be applied.
  • Step #3, On the outer line of your hairline, place a thick line of lotion. This will help prevent dye bleed
  • Step #4, Apply the dye and you can either use a brush or your hands to get the dye down deep to the roots and evenly over all your hair
  • Step #5, Once that is done wait the required time the instructions said you need to wait.
  • Step #6, When that time limit is over, rinse. You can use the sink or the shower that is up to you.

The winner is...

This was a fairly close competition but we have to hand the victory to Just For Men Control GX Grey Reducing Shampoo. The key factor was that it was a shampoo and you could change your hair color whenever you took your regular shower.

Also, there was no wait time in rinsing it out. Other dyes had longer wait times. Then even though the comb through hair dye is very easy, it is not as easy as just shampooing that gray out.


Whether you are for or against men coloring their hair, there may be a time when it is prudent to restore your natural hair color. It could be for work, you just want to look a bit younger or you want to be stylish and show your fashion sense.

Whatever your reason for coloring your hair, it is good to know that you have some fine choices in hair dyes to use. These are as easy or easier than the hair dyes made for women and there is little mess with each one.

Go with the best for you and the dye that offers you a color that matches your natural hair.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply