The Best Beard Butter – Reviews and Top Picks

The Best Beard Butter

We are not going to butter you up.

In other words, we are not going to flatter you. We will tell you about the best beard butter on the market today.

And we will do this by providing you top beard butter reviews, give you a quick overview and comparison chart. We will also answer a few of your questions.

As you may have guessed, beard butter is for beards. Its job is to help men grow a good, healthy beard which makes them look rugged, manly and handsome. It is not easy to find the best beard butter. There are many companies who manufacture the product and they also advertise that they have the best beard butter available. Our job is to guide you to the best ones despite the claims of the many manufacturers out there.

What is Beard Butter

We know the name of the product makes you feel like a piece of toast or pastry. But we do not name the products. We will just guide you to knowing about them, so you can pick the right variety for your beard.

Beard butter is sort of a cross between beard oils and balm. It is less greasy than oil and helps keep your beard soft while stopping beard itch. But it also shares similarities with beard balm. Beard butter also provides the nutrients your beard needs to be healthy.

The Ingredients

The amount of each ingredient each manufacturer places in their style of beard butter is up to them. Each different brand will have different amounts of each ingredient so make sure you read the labels first before purchasing your tin.

Here is a list of the typical ingredients you will find in beard butter:

  • Shea butter

  • Cocoa butter

  • Beeswax

  • Jojoba oil

  • Argan oil

  • Castor oil

  • Vitamin E

  • Essential oils

A Quick Comparison

Wild Willie's Beard Butter

There is nothing wild about this product. All-natural, organic, made by hand in America. This version of beard butter works with your body to help it produce the healthiest beard possible.

This product will keep your facial hair inline and stop the itching.

Detroit Grooming Co. Beard Butter

Another all-natural product that relies on the essential ingredients to help you grow a wonderful looking beard.

This variety conditions your face as well as your beard. It will not leave an oily residue on your skin and the Cedar wood, sweet pipe tobacco, and vanilla's mixed scent will drive the ladies crazy.

Urban Prince Beard Butter

Perfect for dry, brittle or unkempt facial hair. This beard butter will condition, soften, and help you manage the toughest of beards.

In the battle of beard vs beard butter, this variety of beard butter has not met its match.

It works on all types of facial hair and beards.

Polished Gentleman Best All-Natural Beard and Moustache Butter

Made from the finest ingredients found in Australia, New Zealand and other exotic locales.

There are no sulphates, alcohol, gluten, or Parabens involved in the making of this balm/butter. This beard balm/butter is pH balanced for maximum effect.

This beard balm/butter will get you the beard you always wanted.

Maestro's Classic Spirited Beard Butter

This final product moisturises both the skin and the beard hair to give you a great look.

By using Eucalyptus, Rosemary & Juniper Berry you get an invigorating experience as well as a great beard. One difference from all the rest is that this beard butter is water and not oil based which allows it to provide better moisturising effects to your beard.

Our Quick Comparison Chart

Editor's Rating


Wild Willie

1.6 ounces



Detroit Grooming Co.

2 ounces




1.5 ounces (Approx.)



Polished Gentleman

0.8 ounces




8 ounces


Reviews Of The Best Beard Butter on The Market

#1. Wild Willie's Beard Butter

Tradition is a good thing. Having products made the old-fashioned way provides a sense of confidence in the product. You know there are no tricks or gimmicks. The product is sound and will perform as expected. Wild Willie’s beard butter is made from a secret recipe using 13 organic ingredients. There are no chemicals, fragrances or other additives.

This beard butter will allow you to control your hair as it conditions your beard. It will keep the hair follicles moist, fight against the dreaded beard itch. One good thing, it does not leave a weird smell attached to your beard. Women will love the scent it gives off. You do not need a lot of beard butter each time you use it. A little goes a long way.

Wild Willie is so confident that their product will help beard hair growth that thy offer a money back guarantee.

What We Like

  • Made the old-fashioned way.
  • Made in U.S.
  • No chemicals or other additives.

What We Don't Like

  • The price.
  • The size should be larger.

#2. Detroit Grooming Co. Beard Butter

You may not like using beard oil. It may be too runny or greasy for your tastes. This brand of beard butter is just like the porridge in Goldilocks and the three bears. It is just the right consistency.

This variety of beard butter does two things. First it conditions your beard. Your facial hair will feel soft and smooth. Second, it conditions your skin. This duty helps your body produce a healthy, great looking beard. This version of beard butter relies upon the essential ingredients with a few vegetable oils thrown in to make it healthier for you and your beard.

There are no real chemical ingredients to harm you as you use it. The manufacture also gave their product a Cedar wood, sweet pipe tobacco, and vanilla scent that will be attracting a lot of good attention from the opposite sex.

What We Like

  • The scent.
  • The two-pronged attack.
  • Does not rely on chemicals.

What We Don't Like

  • The lack of labelling, particularly missing the list of ingredients.
  • Texture.

#3. Urban Prince Beard Butter

Using this variety of beard butter may make you think you are in the land Oz.

Its blend of Shea Butter, White Beeswax, Jojoba Oil, Argan Oil, Grape Seed Oil, Olive Oil, Coconut Oil, and Vitamin E, will have you thinking something magical is happening to your beard. It is not hard to use.

Don't completely dry your beard. Leave it a little moist when you rub in a little of the beard butter and go from the roots to the tips for the best results.

If you have allergies or sensitive skin, make sure to check with your doctor to see if this beard butter is okay to use. Stop using it if you have any skin irritation or allergic reaction.

Designed to give you maximum holding power without the mess or greasy feel and it also smells great to boot.

What We Like

  • The ingredients.
  • The holding power.
  • The texture.

What We Don't Like

  • The scent.
  • Oily.

#4. Polished Gentleman Best All-Natural Beard and Moustache Butter

We said there may be some confusion about beard butter. It is a cross between oil and balm and this product sides with the balm-butter combination. We are not trying to fool you, but the terms seem to be interchangeable. This product deserves to be on the list given the care its manufacturer gives it.

pH-balanced, all-natural ingredients taken from exotic locales. You can tame, control, style, soften, moisturise and condition your beard all at the same time.

The inclusion of tea tree oil gives this beard balm/butter its unique personality. Not only does it help you grow a great beard it does a lot more. It provides antibacterial, anti-fungal, and antiviral protection, fighting against dandruff, itching, acne, warts, and more.

This balm/butter will also make a man smell like a man. Its cedar fragrance will give off the illusion that you are a man of adventure.

What We Like

  • pH-balanced.
  • Tea tree oil included.
  • Has many health benefits.

What We Don't Like

  • Over the top rhetoric and manufacturer's exaggeration.

#5. Maestro's Classic Spirited Beard Butter

Maestros beard butter gets to the heart of the issue.

It works on moisturising your facial hair while providing it with the essential minerals it needs. Made with Eucalyptus, Rosemary & Juniper Berry you get a smooth beard with little or no itchy problems. All of the ingredients combine to condition your beard for easy grooming, make it soft to the touch as well as very manageable.

Its creamy, light consistency will keep you away from that chapstick texture beard balms bring to the beard wars. Be careful though, its scent may remind you of Vicks Vapour rub or Hall’s throat lozenges.

This beard butter will work on any beard no matter how easy or tough they may be. Make sure you keep your beard a little wet before applying this beard butter.

What We Like

  • Eucalyptus, Rosemary & Juniper.
  • Easy grooming.
  • Moisturising ability.

What We Don't Like

  • Medicinal scent.
  • May become itchy when dried.

The Benefits of Beard Butter

When we say benefits we do not mean you are going to reap great rewards or riches. You may get more attention from the opposite sex which is a great benefit.

But we are not promising anything.

Best Beard Butter

What you will get for certain, however, is a healthier, better looking beard that is soft and easy to style. The best beard butters will bring your face and facial hair all the essential minerals your beard needs to grow right.

How to use Beard Butter

It may take a little practice to get the right amount on your fingertips. When someone says ‘scoop’ they do not mean an ice cream cone scoop size of beard butter. Just a little will do the trick. Here is how to apply your beard butter

  • Put about a fingernail size of beard butter on your fingertips.

  • Rub the amount between your hands to melt it down some.

  • Then massage the butter into your beard and skin. Be thorough.

  • It is okay to take more if you did not take enough the first time.

  • Use a good beard comb or brush to make sure it is spread evenly.

Who Needs Beard Butter

To be honest - no one.

If you let them, beards will grow no matter if you use any beard product or not. But if you value your appearance, like to look good and have healthy skin and facial hair then you do. You will also need beard butter if you like to style your beard and have it stay in place. Then if you like to smell good for the ladies the best beard butter available will enhance your scent. You will smell great and be more attractive.

You do not have to use beard butter but in the long run, but you will be better with it than without.

Some Final Words

To start this off we will pick a winner of this comparison of the best beard butters on the market right now. There is no question about the winner. #1 Wild Willie's Beard Butter is the best and the winner here. Its ingredients, recipe, and old-fashioned traditional method of manufacturing sets it apart and be the competition.

A good beard butter will be better for you and your face. It is a superior product to beard oil and slightly better than beard balm. After reading these reviews you may think that beard butter and beard balm are the same. You may be right. Regardless, if you want a soft, manageable and easy to style beard then you should go for beard butter.

It has the right texture, the perfect ingredients and the right consistency to give you all that you need for a great looking beard. The best beard butters will provide you with all the essential vitamins and minerals your beard and skin need. If you want a healthy beard, then you need to do what doctors used to say. Eat right and your beard needs to ‘eat right’ to be healthy. Take no chances on your face and use the best beard butter on the market.

Leave a Reply